What
image
  • All Listings
  • Art
  • Birthplace
  • Bookstores
  • Cohousing
  • Collectives and Cooperatives
  • Communities
  • Community Centers
  • Eats
  • Ecovillages
  • Egalitarian Communities
  • Entertainment
  • Events
  • Historical Sites
  • Infrastructure
  • Intentional Communities
  • Memorial
  • Monuments
  • Murals
  • People
  • Points of Interests
  • Publishers
  • Sites of Resistance
  • Societies
  • Vegan
  • Venues
  • Workers Associations
Where
image

A Radical World

Élisée Reclus mapped the world for the revolution

Jason Bayless ·


On the morning of July 4, 1905, in a small town in West Flanders called Thourout, Torhout in the Dutch that would eventually settle over the region, a seventy-five-year-old geographer lay dying in a house full of books and unfinished maps. News had been reaching him from the Black Sea. The sailors of the battleship Potemkin had mutinied. Workers in Odessa were in the streets. Something enormous was moving in Russia, and the old man wanted to hear every scrap of it before he went. His last days were reportedly happy ones. He died with the sound of revolt still in the room.

His name was Élisée Reclus. He had spent most of his adult life proving that geography and anarchism were the same discipline studied from different angles. Élisée Reclus reads "Le Cri du People" newspaper in a garden.

Reclus was born in 1830 in Sainte-Foy-la-Grande, a small town in the Dordogne, the second of fourteen children in a Protestant pastor’s household. His father was severe, principled, and poor. The children scattered early into study and radical politics. Reclus and his older brother Élie went to Germany to study under Carl Ritter, one of the founders of modern geography, and came home with two convictions that would never leave them: that the earth was a single interconnected system, and that no authority on it could be justified. They were reading Proudhon by then. Élisée would later read Bakunin and know he had found his companions.

He tried to make a life for himself in France in the 1850s but could not. Louis-Napoléon’s coup had turned the Second Republic into an empire, and Reclus, who refused to swear loyalty to the new regime, left. He spent years wandering, in Ireland, England, the United States, Louisiana, where he watched slavery up close and wrote about it with a rage that never cooled, then Colombia, where he tried and failed to farm. He came back to Paris in 1857 and began the work that would occupy the rest of his life: writing geography as if the planet were a living thing and its human inhabitants were part of it rather than lords over it. He joined the First International. He joined Bakunin’s circle. He wrote for the radical press. When the Prussians laid siege to Paris in 1870, and the imperial government collapsed, Reclus was already in the city, already organized, already ready.

The Paris Commune of spring 1871 was the first sustained attempt in modern Europe to run a large city without a state above it. For seventy-two days, working people governed themselves through elected delegates who could be recalled at any time, separated church from municipal life, canceled rents accumulated during the siege, handed abandoned workshops to the workers who had run them, and declared that the standing army would be replaced by the armed people. Reclus fought as a common soldier in the National Guard. He was captured on April 5, in one of the first sorties against the Versailles troops closing in around the city. He was in prison when the Bloody Week came at the end of May, when the army of the Third Republic entered Paris and killed somewhere between ten and twenty thousand Communards in the streets, in courtyards, against cemetery walls. He survived because he had been captured too early to be among them.

He was sentenced in November 1871 to transportation for life, the penal colony, New Caledonia, the slow death the Republic reserved for its defeated. Scientists across Europe protested. A delegation of English geographers and naturalists intervened. In January 1872, the sentence was commuted to perpetual banishment, and Reclus left France for Switzerland.

He settled first in Lugano, then in Clarens on Lake Geneva, and there he built the life that would make him one of the most influential geographers of the nineteenth century and one of the most influential anarchists. He began work on the Nouvelle Géographie universelle, a nineteen-volume description of the entire inhabited world, which he would spend nearly twenty years writing. He wrote it in longhand, from correspondents’ reports, from travelers’ accounts, from his own memory of the places he had walked. Publishers paid him well for it. He used the money to fund anarchist journals and support exiled comrades. He worked alongside Peter Kropotkin, who had escaped from a Russian prison in 1876 and made his way to Switzerland. The two of them, geographers, became the theoretical center of the anarchist movement in exile.

In 1879, the French Republic issued an amnesty for the Communards. Reclus could have gone home. He did not. He stayed in exile because exile was where the work was, and because he had no interest in accommodating himself to a state that had murdered his comrades. When the French authorities put Kropotkin and other anarchists on trial in Lyon in 1883, the prosecution named Reclus as one of the leading promoters of anarchism in Europe. Being domiciled in Switzerland, he escaped imprisonment. Kropotkin got five years.

In 1894, the Free University of Brussels offered Reclus a chair in comparative geography, and he moved with his family to Belgium. The offer was withdrawn under pressure from conservatives who objected to his politics, he had defended the anarchist Auguste Vaillant, who had thrown a bomb into the French Chamber of Deputies, and Reclus, along with the professors who resigned in solidarity, founded a new institution, the Université Nouvelle, in the same year. He taught there for the rest of his life. He lived quietly, wrote constantly, ate no meat (he had written against the slaughter of animals as part of the same violence that produced war and empire), and welcomed a steady traffic of anarchists, geographers, students, and exiles through his door.

His last book, L’Homme et la terre, Man and the Earth, was six volumes long and finished just before he died. It is the summation of everything he had been arguing for fifty years. Geography is not a neutral science. The way human beings organize themselves on the earth is a political question. Mountains and rivers shape societies, but so do property law, standing armies, and the borders drawn by treaties. Freedom, for Reclus, was not an abstract right. It was the concrete condition of a species that had finally understood itself as part of the planet it lived on and stopped trying to dominate either the earth or each other. He wrote against colonialism when most European geographers were mapping Africa for the colonial ministries. He wrote against private property in land. He wrote against the death penalty, against militarism, against the caging of animals in zoos. He believed that anarchism was the political form of ecological truth, and that ecology without anarchism was a lie the powerful told about the world.

He was buried at Ixelles Cemetery in Brussels. His brother Élie had died the year before. Kropotkin outlived him by sixteen years and would die in Soviet Russia, having watched the revolution he had waited for all his life turn into something he could not recognize.

The tradition Reclus was part of did not end with him. It lived through the Spanish anarchists who read him in the collectives of Aragón and Catalonia in 1936. It lived through the Italian anarchist exiles who carried his books across the Atlantic. It lives in the geographers who now teach political ecology and cite him as an ancestor, and in the anarchist federations that still meet in the cities where he lived. Belgium has an active anarchist scene. France’s Fédération anarchiste maintains groups across the country, including the Groupe Germinal in Marseille and the Groupe Gard-Vaucluse, organizing along lines Reclus would recognize: federated, horizontal, refusing the state as a partner. The Anarchist Black Cross network that supports imprisoned anarchists worldwide, from Dresden to Copenhagen to Moscow, does the same work of solidarity across borders that Reclus and Kropotkin did for their comrades in the 1870s.

The Potemkin mutiny that Reclus heard about in his last days was the opening act of the 1905 revolution in Russia, which was crushed within months and returned twelve years later as something the Tsar could not survive. The sailors he heard about were young men who had refused to eat rotten meat and then refused to be shot for refusing, and who took a battleship and sailed it into revolt. Reclus, who had written about the earth as a single system in which no part was ever really separate from any other, would have understood exactly why that story reached him in Flanders and made him glad.

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

A RADICAL NEWSLETTER

A newsletter about building alternatives. One email a month.

Subscribe →